Trophy-gate 2020: Discarded trophies cause uproar at local school district

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather

  At a time when schools should be concentrating on preparing for the coming school year — a school year in the time of COVID-19 and where teachers are shifting their paradigm from face-to-face teaching to online only — the Mammoth-San Manuel School District is coming under fire for a dumpster full of trophies.

What Happened?

  On Monday, Aug. 3, photos and comments began flooding Facebook and NextDoor of a dumpster full of school trophies.

  Randall Yubeta, a member of the Class of 2006, emailed the members of the school board and San Manuel Miner to voice his outrage at the sight of so many trophies being discarded.

  “There is absolutely no excuse for this type of disregard for the hard work that thousands of alumni have put in not only in the classroom but the fields and areas of competition that these trophies represent,” Yubeta wrote in his email.

  The trophies were located in a commercial Waste Management dumpster on school property.

  According to a post on the school district’s Facebook page, “There was a recent upset in the community due to trophies being found in the dumpster. When it was brought to the administration’s attention, the trophies were retrieved and are now in storage. The trophy cases in the gym were cleaned and the plan was to make them look more presentable. They now house our many championship trophies so that they can be seen. This should have never occurred and we apologize for upsetting the community over this matter. Administration will look further into this matter and deal with any disciplinary action that should occur.”

  The district’s initial plan was to photograph the trophies for older invitationals and tournaments and then offer the trophies to alumni. 

Administration’s Response

  In an email to the San Manuel Miner, Julie Dale-Scott, Superintendent of the Mammoth-San Manuel School District said:

  “The circumstances that occurred with the Miner trophies is a misunderstanding. It was not something that was planned or directed. I realize that the Mammoth-San Manuel community is one that has had a lot of loss, to start with its copper mine and on to several schools and business closures. It therefore is disturbing that this event has even occurred. 

  “The actual intent, was to showcase the achievements that created our Miner pride. Currently, the trophy cases in the gym highlight our achievements over the last 67 years in each sport and our hope is that we can add more eventually. We are very proud of all Miners and realize as educators that not everyone is a bookworm and each of our Miner family has a different talent. Athletics is a bridge to education for some students. Students try harder in their academics because they really want to be on the field or court. Athletics build confidence and the right coaching can create opportunities. Some of our athletes have gone on to play in college, the semipros, and even on professional teams. We are very proud that they call themselves a Miner.

  “My hope after retrieving those trophies is to work with our community members to not only find a way to treasure those trophies, but continue to build on our Miner pride. We need to honor the past and allow our young students that continue through our small school to feel what Miner pride is as well by adding new memories.”

Staff (5530 Posts)

There are news or informational items frequently written by staff or submitted to the Copper Basin News, San Manuel Miner, Superior Sun, Pinal Nugget or Oracle Towne Crier for inclusion in our print or digital products. These items are not credited with an author.


Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather
Facebooktwitterby feather

Comments are closed.

  • Additional Stories

    Superior Police welcome new officer to their ranks

    September 16th, 2020
    by

      The Town of Superior has a new full-time police officer. Jessica Brown was hired on Aug. 31, 2020, and […]


    Carlos Salazar

    September 16th, 2020
    by

    September 4, 2020   Carlos Salazar, 86, passed from natural causes in Oro Valley on Sept. 4, 2020.  He is […]


    Michael Thomas Welfel

    September 16th, 2020
    by

      Michael Thomas Welfel passed away Aug. 23, 2020.   Michael was born Dec. 13, 1953 in New York City […]


    Oracle Firewise recognized for 15 years of service

    September 16th, 2020
    by

    By John Hernandez San Manuel Miner  On Wednesday, Sept. 9, 2020, Aaron Casem, State Prevention Officer for the Arizona Department […]


  • Additional Stories

    Mammoth Police Report – September 16, 2020

    September 16th, 2020
    by

    MPR 9-16   According to state law, there are two methods by which police may arrest suspected offenders. The suspect […]


    3C Ranch celebrates restaurant reopening following pandemic shutdown

    September 16th, 2020
    by

      On Saturday and Sunday, Sept. 12 and 13, the 3C Ranch celebrated its grand reopening of its restaurant with […]


    Hayden-Winkelman Unified School District “Meals on Wheels” to continue throughout 2020

    September 16th, 2020
    by

      Hayden-Winkelman Unified School District received some great news this week and will be able to continue delivering and serving […]


    Superintendent receives Bastion of Courage Award

    September 16th, 2020
    by

      Hayden-Winkelman Unified School District Superintendent Jeff Gregorich received the Arizona School Administration “Bastion of Courage Award” for his efforts […]


  • Copperarea

  • Southeast Valley Ledger