PRFR numbers for tax estimates given incorrectly

Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather

In his comment about my Letter to the Editor on August 13, 2014, James Hodl still appears to be confused about how to calculate the expected taxes for the proposed Pinal Rural Fire Rescue and Medical District (PRFR&MD). The most accurate approach is what I outlined using the rightmost column of the impact statement for each parcel. That is, take the Primary Net Assessed value given in this column and multiple it by 3%. The correctness of this calculation of taxes that I presented verbally and in a handout was confirmed in an email to me on 8/11/14 from Steve Turcotte in which he stated “You are correct in your calculations using the figures on the far right column of the spreadsheet as your base assessment.”

Supervisor Todd House suggested that the Full Cash Value could be used to calculate the potential taxes if it were multiplied by 10% to give an estimate of the Primary Net Assessed Value. This amount could then be multiplied by 3% to give the tax amount. First, the Primary Net Assessed values I used were already multiplied by percentage rate making a second multiplication by 10% as Todd House suggested incorrect. Second, his approach is more approximate than what I recommended (the actual rate on our two parcels is not 10% but 10.6% and 16.0%) and these differences are reflected in the value in the rightmost column.

Unfortunately, in addition the examples in the PRFR&MD impact statement incorrectly suggest using the Secondary Net Assessment value (second column from the right), a value which has already been multiplied by around 10%. For their method, they should instead suggest using the Full Cash Value (fourth column from the right), which is about ten times higher, before first multiplying by 10%, and then by 3%.

In other words, the numbers that I gave for the amount of property taxes and the potential increase in the property taxes of 32.4% are correct. Todd House was wrong in his estimate of what the taxes would be and fittingly at the Board of Supervisors meeting he would not guarantee to me that his claim that the taxes would be 1/10 of what I had calculated. It should be clear that the increase in taxes from the proposed district will be substantial and will increase our property taxes by nearly one-third. The grossly incorrect calculations of property taxes suggested by the supporters of PRFR&MD makes me concerned that many other statements by them might also be incorrect.

/s/ Phil Hedrick

Winkelman

Editor’s Note: Copper Area News writer James Hodl used the property tax estimates that were presented to the Pinal County Board of Supervisors by Pinal Rural Fire Rescue because they were part of the official record of the meeting and the impact statement. The group has a year to gather signatures in favor of the new district and it’s voices like Mr. Hedrick’s that will provide counterpoints to the issue. We at Copper Area News appreciate differing viewpoints and invite others to participate in the community discussion. ~JRC

Staff (4054 Posts)

There are news or informational items frequently written by staff or submitted to the Copper Basin News, San Manuel Miner, Superior Sun, Pinal Nugget or Oracle Towne Crier for inclusion in our print or digital products. These items are not credited with an author.


Facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmailby feather
Facebooktwitterby feather

Comments are closed.

  • Additional Stories

    Letter to the Editor: Dad Was There

    June 15th, 2017
    by

      June is here, with Father’s Day coming up, it’s time to honor the dads!   I am so thankful […]


    Along the Gila: Wildcat Dumping in the Copper Corridor

    June 15th, 2017
    by

    In 1971, the cartoonist Walt Kelly drew a two-panel set featuring Pogo and his friend Porkypine. The first panel shows […]


    An Open Letter to the Mammoth San Manuel Unified School District

    May 18th, 2017
    by

      There is a quote most often attributed to Ralph Waldo Emerson, “enjoy the journey not  the destination”. For the […]


    Mayor’s Minute: Graduates & Projects

    May 11th, 2017
    by

    This year is flying by so quickly. Our school district will be celebrating graduation on May 26 and in honor […]


  • Additional Stories

    Letter to the Editor: Special Gifts

    May 11th, 2017
    by

      May is the time of year, when we honor all our mothers and thank them for all that they […]


    Letter to the Editor: Possible repeat of history?

    May 11th, 2017
    by

      I am sure that it is because of my worries of what is happening now and may happen in […]


    Along the Gila: Kearny Makes Police Chief Selection

    May 11th, 2017
    by

    Good news for Kearny. At the special meeting of Town Council last week, the selection of Joseph Turitto was made […]


    Letter to the Editor: Random acts of kindness

    May 4th, 2017
    by

      Thanks to the generosity of Jenny and Bill Holmquist, who now own Porter’s Cafe, four local non-profits now have […]


  • Copperarea

  • [Advertisement.]
  • [Advertisement.]
  • [Advertisement.]
  • Southeast Valley Ledger